A great many restaurants have Caesar salad on their menus, most often pizzerias and Italian restaurants. Yet you rarely get a genuine Caesar; quite often it turns out to be iceberg lettuce with some mayonnaise dressing of a dull colour and unimpressive flavour. Caesar salad is a great favourite of mine, so I order it at almost every restaurant I visit for the first time, and so far I have not found one that comes close to the original. Let's take a closer look at the history of this world classic and then show you how to make a completely authentic version at home.
Although you might think Caesar salad comes from Europe, it does not. The father of the salad was the Italian Caesar Cardini (1896-1956), who left his native Italy with his brother Alex after the end of the First World War and moved to the USA. Cardini lived in San Diego in the United States, but because of Prohibition he started running a restaurant in Tijuana, Mexico, just under 17 miles away.
The salad Cardini served in his restaurant soon became very popular and sought after. Many conjectures and conflicting claims about the original recipe and the salad's name still circulate today. Cardini's partner Paul Maggiora, for example, claimed that the first Caesar salad was served in 1927 to American soldiers in San Diego and was called "Aviator's Salad" — meaning a pilot's or aviator's salad ... Cardini's brother Alex claimed the recipe was his creation and also called it Aviator's Salad. The cook Livio Santini claimed it was his mother's recipe and that he prepared this salad in Cardini's restaurant in 1925, when he was 18 years old, and therefore deserved credit for its creation.
Caesar salad supposedly served a similar purpose to the garlic soup we Czechs turn to on bleary mornings. Prohibition was in force, American soldiers flocked to Tijuana, spent the night carousing and often had the salad in the morning to get them back on their feet with a hangover. At least that is what Caesar's brother Alex said. He later moved to Mexico City, opened three restaurants and put "the original Alex Cardini Caesar salad" on the menu — meaning Alex Cardini's original Caesar salad.
Caesar Cardini, on the other hand, moved to Los Angels in 1938 and opened a gourmet shop with his daughter Rosa. He capitalised on the popularity of the Caesar salad dressing and began selling it in jars as Cardini's original Caesar dressing.
As for the name Caesar salad, it is actually translated into Czech somewhat inaccurately as Caesar salát; from a linguistic perspective, the correct translation should be Caesarův salát or Salát Caesar.
So let's look at what an original Caesar salad looks like, what makes it special and what goes into it. The recipe has changed slightly over time, so the Caesar we eventually make at home will be the version considered correct today. Still, it does no harm to revisit the original recipe for comparison. The salad is based on ingredients that were readily available in Mexico at the time.
Garlic croutons — the original recipe calls for a baguette, in other words white bread, cut into pieces and fried in oil with garlic. In Alex Cardini's recipe the croutons were also spread with anchovy paste; Caesar's recipe adds the croutons as they are, with the garlic going into the dressing.
Romaine lettuce — no lettuce other than romaine is acceptable. The original recipe contains whole romaine leaves; today we mostly encounter torn or chopped leaves.
A fresh egg, boiled for exactly 1 minute — the yolk is used. This is what is known as a "coddled egg" ... a briefly boiled, or indeed pampered, egg. It is essentially a soft-boiled egg in which the white sets and the yolk thickens slightly during the minute of cooking.
Lemon or lime juice. We do not know which Caesar Cardini used, because in Mexico they call limes lemons. Limes were, however, more common in Mexico.
Grated Parmesan — Parmesan is neither Grana Panada nor Grand Moravia. Parmesan must bear the name "Parmigiano Reggiano". This mark is branded onto the outer rind; that is how you recognise the real thing. To bear this seal, it must follow a prescribed recipe and be made in the specified region. Of course, it is true that other Parmesan-style cheeses made outside the region may follow the recipe too; the most common departure in the production process is the use of non-natural rennet. Nevertheless, Italians swear by original Parmesan.
Worcestershire sauce — the original recipe used only Worcestershire sauce, whereas Alex Cardini used crushed anchovies. These are used today too, and sometimes even whole anchovy fillets are laid on top.
The original recipe (the salad was supposedly prepared "Table side" in Cardini's restaurant, meaning that a waiter made the dish on a trolley right in front of the guests in the dining room) says to take a sufficiently large bowl and put the whole romaine leaves into it. Add several tablespoons of olive oil, season with salt and pepper and coat the leaves thoroughly by turning them over. Then pour in lemon or lime juice and 12 drops of Worcestershire sauce. Next add the yolk from the egg boiled for a minute as described above, and again mix it into the salad by turning the leaves over. Add half a cup of grated Parmesan and the croutons, and toss again. That finishes the job, and the dish is served on a plate. The salad could also be eaten without cutlery, just with your hands.
More details on the history and original recipe here: http://www.kitchenproject.com/history/CaesarSalad/index.htm
Now let's make ourselves a little "Caesar" at home, in the version considered standard today.
Ingredients:
Leaves from a head of romaine lettuce, preferably young and crisp
1 egg
olive oil
3 anchovy fillets
1 tablespoon Dijon mustard
baguette or white bread
1 large garlic clove
Parmesan — both shaved and grated
1 lime
Worcestershire sauce, salt, pepper
And off we go. Separate the romaine lettuce into leaves. It is important to wash the leaves thoroughly, but handle them carefully. The leaves must stay crisp and fresh; once we bruise them, they lose their magic. The same applies to drying. The lettuce leaves must be completely dry before their bath in the dressing so that it clings to them, so we pay particular attention to drying. We can use a salad spinner, or perhaps the following trick described by Gordon Ramsay in his book Kitchen Heaven. Take a clean, dry tea towel, put a few leaves inside, grasp the ends and spin it, or at least give it a swing. A sensible amount of centrifugal force will do the job, but again, be careful not to damage the leaves by being overenthusiastic. Then put the leaves somewhere cold so that they are as fresh as possible before serving. Leafy vegetables in general should go straight into the fridge after harvesting and stay there until the very last moment before serving.
Next we prepare the croutons. According to Alex, the garlic went with the croutons; according to Caesar, it went into the dressing. I prefer garlic as part of the dressing. We can cut the baguette or white bread into slices or larger cubes. First put these in the oven to dry out. Spread them on a baking tray and put them in the oven at a low temperature — say 75°C — until the bread has dried out a little. This is particularly necessary with fresh bread. Heat olive oil in a frying pan and sauté the croutons.
Now let's turn to the dressing, the most important part of the whole recipe. If you make some in advance, it can be kept in the fridge for a while.
First we need an egg yolk. While professional kitchens must use pasteurised yolks for hygiene reasons, at home we will use a yolk from a fresh egg. How do you recognise a fresh egg? Ideally, the hen has just laid it, or did so no more than 10 days ago. But if we do not know how old the egg is, how do we find out? First of all, the egg should be intact; that is the first and simplest test. We can also shake the egg next to our ear. In a fresh egg the yolk and white are closely bound together; in older eggs they separate, and the egg makes a sort of sloshing sound. A third option is to submerge the egg in water. A fresh egg will stubbornly stay at the bottom; an older egg starts to float near the surface.
We can also use the original method, a "coddled egg" — in other words, a briefly boiled or pampered egg. Bring water to the boil; once it is boiling, put in the egg and cook for exactly a minute. Then immediately transfer it to cold water to stop it cooking any further. Take the yolk from this pampered egg and put it in a bowl.
Add a tablespoon of Dijon mustard and the lime juice. It helps to put the lime in the microwave for 10 seconds before cutting it open; the juice will then be much easier to squeeze out. I recommend starting with the juice of half a lime and only adding more to taste at the end of the process, if needed. Bear in mind that the limes sold here are unripe and very tart, whereas in the countries they come from they are much sweeter.
Take a whisk and start beating the mixture of lime juice, egg yolk and Dijon mustard until the yolk becomes frothy.
Peel the garlic, remove the germ, which can cause digestive problems for many people, crush it in a garlic press and add it, along with half a teaspoon of Worcestershire sauce. Next finely chop and crush the anchovy fillets with a knife, and add finely grated Parmesan. Take the whisk again and start whisking the contents of the bowl.
When the mixture is thoroughly combined and thickened, start adding olive oil drop by drop, stirring constantly. We may find we have run out of hands. One hand holds the bowl, the other works the whisk, so how do we pour in the oil? If we put the bowl on a rubber mat or perhaps a tea towel, it will stop spinning under the whisk, we will no longer need to hold it, and we can happily put the other hand to use. Stir very vigorously.
If the Czech term ančovičky means nothing to you, it refers to anchovies, also called sardele in Czech (not sardines), so in a shop you are more likely to find them labelled sardelové filety, packed in oil. Definitely do not use anchovy paste, though, as it is too strongly flavoured. Keep whisking and adding the oil very slowly. The more oil we add, the thicker the dressing will be.
Finally, season the dressing with salt and freshly ground black pepper, taste it and add more lime juice if needed.
The last part is putting it all together. Put the romaine leaves into an empty bowl. We can either tear them carefully or cut them into suitably sized pieces. There are two opposing views on dividing the leaves: some advocate tearing, others cutting. I think it makes no difference in the end. Pour a little dressing into the bowl of leaves and toss gently. Then keep adding dressing and tossing. What matters is that every single lettuce leaf is coated in a thin layer of dressing that does not run off it. When tossing, take care not to bruise or damage the leaves. I repeat that it is essential for the lettuce leaves to be completely dry before mixing them with the dressing. Do not overdo the dressing: it has a very strong flavour, so there is no need for the lettuce leaves to swim in it.
Once we are satisfied, we can serve. Ideally on a chilled plate. Transfer the leaves to the plate, scatter over fresh Parmesan shavings, add the croutons and serve immediately. This dish depends on perfect, perfectly fresh ingredients. Lettuce that has dried out or has not been dried properly, older Parmesan or an egg that is not entirely fresh can spoil it.
Restaurants sometimes serve Caesar salad with chicken, in which case the menu must say Caesar salad with chicken. If other ingredients are added, they should be mentioned too, because Caesar most definitely does not contain any bacon by default, let alone cucumbers or tomatoes and other nonsense.
Enjoy your meal.