When we hear chicken in paprika sauce, we probably picture a familiar home-cooked classic. This time, though, we'll take a peek into Hungary and cook their csirkepaprikás. We'll keep nice big pieces of meat on the plate and give the sauce the flavour of paprika and the gentle tang of sour cream. The absolutely classic accompaniment to this dish is nokedli, little pasta dumplings.
A little history before we get the pot out
According to Magyar Konyha magazine, one of the early printed records is the recipe “Paprikás tsibe” in the fourth edition of István Czifray's cookbook from 1830. The same overview also lists chicken paprikash on a handwritten menu belonging to Nyíregyháza innkeeper Márkus Mihály from 1834. We would have paid eighteen kreuzers for it. References to meat with paprika are older, though. So we won't present 1830 as the year someone first thought of throwing chicken into a pot with paprika.
(Source: Magyar Konyha – Paprikás tsibe)
We'd rather not start any kitchen wars over the names paprikás and pörkölt. These days, restaurants commonly call the version with cream paprikash, but the historical use of those words isn't quite so tidy. Magyar Konyha points out that the name paprikash was also associated with a larger amount of cooking juices and didn't always mean cream had been added. This time we'll choose the home-style version with sour cream. And we'll keep the chicken on the bone for good, rich cooking juices, as the same overview recommends. We won't bother with little boneless cubes today.
(Source: Magyar Konyha – chicken and its traditional preparations)
Ingredients: chicken thighs, or other bone-in chicken pieces, onions, lard, good-quality sweet paprika (Hungarian, not Spanish), a pale green pepper (the kind known as Slovak), a small ripe tomato, full-fat sour cream, plain flour, salt, a little pepper to taste, chicken stock (or water), chilli to suit each comrade's taste.
We'll pay a bit of attention to the seasoning this time. We'll reach for fragrant sweet paprika; we'll save the smoked stuff for another dish. Add hot paprika only to taste. We don't need to turn paprikash into an entrance exam for the fire brigade.
Let's get started
Finely chop the onion, and the fresh pepper and tomato too. Pat the meat dry and salt it. Heat the lard in a wide pot and brown the chicken until golden. Then set it aside, add the onion and let it caramelise over a low heat.
Take the pot off the heat, stir in the ground paprika and immediately pour in the stock. Return to the heat, add the chopped vegetables and simmer briefly. Put in the chicken and add enough water to come roughly halfway up it.
Cover and simmer gently for approximately 45–60 minutes, or longer depending on the size and type of chicken, until the meat is fully cooked and tender. Carefully turn the pieces and top up the liquid a little at a time as needed. If there's too much cooking liquid, let it reduce uncovered before thickening.
Mix the sour cream with the flour. Gradually stir in two small ladlefuls of the hot cooking liquid, then pour the mixture into the pot. Stir gently, simmer lightly for several minutes and adjust the seasoning. Let's avoid any furious bubbling. Reduce until we have a sauce for the dumplings, rather than soup.
And now for the nokedli
For four portions, we'll need 400 g plain flour, 2 eggs, about 220–250 ml water and salt. We'll also need a little lard or oil for the cooked dumplings.
Mix the eggs with the water and salt, add the flour and briefly bring together into a thick, sticky dough. Add the water gradually as needed. Push small pieces through a halušky sieve into boiling salted water, or cut them off a board into the water. Personally, I'm clumsy at cutting them off, so I use that perforated halušky sieve. Once the dumplings float to the surface, let them cook for another 2 min. Drain and toss with a little lard, otherwise they'll stick together.
Well, hopefully I haven't got it all muddled up and Hungary won't declare war on us.